Second, they agree that authentic consent is the sine qua non of legitimate sex, whether in commercial or non-commercial form. Third, all feminists recognize that commercial sex workers are subject to economic coercion and are often victims of violence, and that little is done to address these problems.
An analysis of prostitution, they agree that authentic consent is the sine qua non of legitimate sex, whether in commercial or non-commercial form. Third, all feminists recognize that commercial sex workers are subject to economic coercion and are often victims of violence, and that little is done to An analysis of prostitution these problems.
The sex work perspective, the abolitionist perspective and the outlaw perspective. The sex work perspective maintains that prostitution is a legitimate form of work for women faced with the option of other bad jobs, therefore women ought to have the right to work in the sex trade free of prosecution or the fear of it.
The sex work perspective also argues that governments should eliminate laws that criminalize voluntary prostitution. This, the sex work perspective asserts, will allow prostitution to be regulated by governments and business codes, protect sex trade workers, and improve the ability to prosecute people who hurt them.
The Abolitionist perspective holds that governments should work towards the elimination of prostitution. Advertisements for prostitutes fill a phone booth Coercion and poverty[ edit ] See also: Survival sex These feminists do argue that, in most cases, prostitution is not a conscious and calculated choice.
They say that most women who become prostitutes do so because they were forced or coerced by a pimp or by human trafficking, or, when it is an independent decision, it is generally the result of extreme poverty and lack of opportunity, or of serious underlying problems, such as drug addiction, past trauma such as child sexual abuse and other unfortunate circumstances.
These feminists point out that women from the lowest socioeconomic classes—impoverished women, women with a low level of education, women from the most disadvantaged racial and ethnic minorities—are overrepresented in prostitution all over the world.
The money thus acts as a form of force, not as a measure of consent. It acts like physical force does in rape. Barbara Sullivan says, "In the academic literature on prostitution there are very few authors who argue that valid consent to prostitution is possible.
Most suggest that consent to prostitution is impossible or at least unlikely. For radical feminists this is because prostitution is always a coercive sexual practice. Others simply suggest that economic coercion makes the sexual consent of sex workers highly problematic if not impossible Those of us who say this are accused of being simple-minded.
But prostitution is very simple. And no woman gets whole again later, after. These feminists argue that sexual liberation for women cannot be achieved as long as we normalize unequal sexual practices where a man dominates a woman. They say that the act of prostitution is not a mutual and equal sex act as it puts the woman in a subordinate position, reducing her to a mere instrument of sexual pleasure for the client.
These feminists believe that many clients use the services of prostitutes because they enjoy the "power trip" they derive from the act and the control they have over the woman during the sexual activity.
Anti-prostitution feminists argue that when a society accepts prostitution it sends the message that it is irrelevant how the woman feels during sex or what the consequences of sex will be for her, and that it is acceptable for a man to engage in sexual activity with a woman who does not enjoy it and who could be mentally and emotionally forcing herself in order to be able to cope; the normalization of such one sided sexual encounters might negatively affect the way men relate to women in general and might increase sexual violence against women.
These feminists see prostitution as a form of slavery, and say that, far from decreasing rape rates, prostitution leads to a sharp increase in sexual violence against women, by sending the message that it is acceptable for a man to treat a woman as a sexual instrument over which he has total control.
Legal prostitution creates an atmosphere in this state in which women are not humans equal to them, are disrespected by men, and which then sets the stage of increased violence against women.
Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met.
December See also: Forced prostitution Some feminists, including many who identify as supporting the abolition of prostitution, see the selling of sex as a potential after effect of violence against women.
Those who support this position cite studies of violence experienced by women in prostitution prior to entering prostitution. Studies of women in prostitution show an extremely high level of violence is perpetrated against women in prostitution.
Figures vary across studies. Many brothels have installed panic buttons because of the ongoing threat of violence indoors. Beyond the individual instances of violence or the history of violence suffered by most women in prostitution, prostitution abolitionists see prostitution itself as a form of male violence against women and children.
Similarly, in other forms of violence against women, anti-violence feminists expect women who are battered, raped, incested, harassed and threatened will not be punished for the crimes committed against them, while the male perpetrators, mostly known to the victims, will suffer criminalization in accordance with the law.
Prostitution abolitionists also cite similarities between prostitution and violence against women. Farley, Lynne and Cotton argue the prostitution is most like battery because it similarly involves a pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour by pimps, procurers and traffickers as well as clients that results in the control of the women in prostitution.
Some analysts on human rights issues surrounding prostitution, such as Sigma Huda in her report for the United Nations Commission on Human Rights, also adopt this approach:Before World War II, we witnessed the purification movement, on which Christian groups embarked as moral entrepreneurs.
After the war, female groups took the initiative in a movement for anti‐prostitution law. The movement resulted in the enactment of the Prostitution Prevention Law in , which made prostitution a punishable criminal offense.
Legalizing prostitution does go against the advice of Cultural Marxists and Karl Marx himself, but in today’s society of supposedly empowered women not legalizing it because women are still victims is the height of hypocrisy.
Using this supply-demand analysis, we can theorize how the legalization of prostitution would affect sex trafficking. The legalization of prostitution will expand the sex services market, which is likely to include both voluntary and coerced labor.
Before World War II, we witnessed the purification movement, on which Christian groups embarked as moral entrepreneurs.
After the war, female groups took the initiative in a movement for anti‐prostitution law. The movement resulted in the enactment of the Prostitution Prevention Law in , which made prostitution a punishable criminal offense. Sex Work and the Law: A Critical Analysis of Four Policy Approaches to Adult Prostitution - Throughout Sex Work and the Law: A Critical Analysis of Four Policy Approaches to Adult Prostitution Frances Shaver discusses the need for change for women working as prostitutes.
In addition, anyone who wishes to start a prostitution business would have to apply for a permit. From the Top Down. Various actors involved in the world of prostitution have different opinions about the current situation, and the future of the sex trade in general.